Birthright citizenship must stay

The first sentence of the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution says this: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State where they reside.”

Donald J. Trump wants to get rid of that right of those born in this country. Birthright citizenship, he said, must be repealed. Trump said also that he’s the man who’ll do it.

Whoa! Let’s hold on a minute, shall we?

Amending the Constitution requires a whole lot more than merely a presidential declaration. Repealing birthright citizenship would require a super-majority of both houses of Congress to approve it, Then it would require a super-majority of the 50 state legislatures in the United States of America to approve it.

This action goes far beyond a president’s ability — or authority — to make it happen.

This is part of Trump’s anti-immigrant view, which is articulated by many senior advisers within the administration he has created. He wants to stem what he calls the “invasion” of immigrants across our southern border. Many of those immigrants — chiefly the undocumented among them — are bring unborn children with them. Therefore, he reckons that this country cannot afford to have children born to those who are here illegally, but who become U.S. citizens the moment they draw breath.

The amendment was ratified in July 1868 and has served as a beacon for those seeking opportunity in the “land of opportunity.” Trump’s desire to shoo away those seeking a better life in this great nation ignores one of our great land’s basic tenets … which is to welcome everyone born within our borders.

4 thoughts on “Birthright citizenship must stay”

  1. It definitely needs to be modified. It’s ridiculous the number of criminals that are crossing the border and harming our citizens. Does Laken Riley come to mind. I believe there were over 60 democrats that voted AGAINST Laken Riley’s bill.

    If you cross the border ILLEGALLY and have a kid here, that kid should be here illegally as well. If you want asylum, cross the border legally!

    I’m waiting on an article denouncing Biden’s chicken shit pardoning of his family. What do they have to hide? Also, why did Fauci need a pardon? What illegal act did he perform? Must be something there or he wouldn’t have done this. As corrupt as Biden is, he’s definitely protecting his own ass.

    1. BJ – You’ve missed the point (as you so often do). The point is that a president cannot change the Constitution through an executive order. As John has explained, it takes much more than that. Surely Trump knows this. It’s performative politics.

  2. Thanks Ted! I’m sure Trump knows more than Biden on the constitution and the 28 amendments. LOL!

Comments are closed.